Newspaper Archive of
The Message
Evansville, Indiana
August 23, 1996     The Message
PAGE 10     (10 of 16 available)        PREVIOUS     NEXT      Full Size Image
PAGE 10     (10 of 16 available)        PREVIOUS     NEXT      Full Size Image
August 23, 1996

Newspaper Archive of The Message produced by SmallTownPapers, Inc.
Website © 2020. All content copyrighted. Copyright Information.     Terms Of Use.     Request Content Removal.

0 The Message -- for Catholics of Southwestern Indiana August 23, 1996 III I I Cardinal Law finds 'Called to be Catholic' flawed BOSTON (CNS) -- Cardinal Bernard F. Law of Boston has described as flawed and "not very helpful" the framework statement on which Cardinal Joseph L. Bernardin of Chicago has based a Catholic unity pro- ject. He said the "pastoral crisis" Cardinal Bernardin is attempt- ing to address cannot be resolved by making "truth and dissent from truth.., equal partners in ecclesial dialogue." "It is, I think, unfortunate that the cardinal's initiative has tied itself to this statement," Cardi- nal Law said Aug. 12,just hours after Cardinal Bernardin an- nounced his initiative. "The statement is not very helpful," Cardinal Law added. 'nroughout there are gratuitous assumptions, and at significant points it breathes an ideological bias which it elsewhere decries in others. The fundamental flaw in this document is its appeal for 'dialogue' as a path to 'common ground." The statement at issue is titled "Called to be Catholic." It was drawn up by the New York-based National Pastoral Life Center in consultation with Cardinal Bernardin and a number of other U.S. Catholic leaders. The statement says the per- sistent polarization in the U.S. Catholic community threatens to sap its vitality and undermine the church's needed witness in society. It criticizes both the so-called left and the so-called right for contributing to a climate of dis- trust and antagonism that make constructive dialogue and collab- oration difficult. Cardinal Law noted that about two-thirds of the way through the framework statement is "the thought that 'Jesus Christ, pre- sent in Scripture and sacrament, is central to all we do; he must always be the measure and not what is measured."' "I would have preferred to have the statement begin at that point," he said. "The crisis the church is facing can only be ade- quately addressed by a clarion call to conversion." "Dialogue as applied to this pastoral crisis must be clearly understood," the Boston prelate commented. "Dissent from revealed truth or the authoritative teaching of the church cannot be 'dialogued' away. Truth and dissent from truth are not equal partners in ecclesial dialogue," he added. "Di- alogue as a pastoral effort to as- sist in a fuller appropriation of the truth is laudable. Dialogue as a way to mediate between the truth and dissent is mutual de- ception." He said that the "common ground" for Catholics "is found in sacred Scripture and tradition, and it is mediated to us through the authoritative and binding teaching of the magisterium." "The disconnect that is so often found today between that Catholic common ground and faith and practice of some Catholics is alarming," he said. He questioned what the state- ment meant by introducing the Bishop Pilla hopes Bernardin initiative will succeed WASHINGTON (CNS) -- Bishop Anthony M. Pilla, presi- dent of the National Conference of Catholic Bishops, said he hopes the Catholic unity initiative by Chicago's Cardinal Joseph L. Bernardin will achieve its goal. "I pray ior this effort and hope the cardinal's stated purpose and goal of better understand- ing and reconciliation can be achieved," he said in a brief statement Aug. 13. "The cardinal has indicated that this effort will be made in the context of church teaching and tradition," Bishop Pilla said. "I have every reason to believe that the cardinal has.taken this initiative because of his love and concern for the church." Bishop Pilla praised Cardinal Bernardin, 68, saying he has "served the Holy See, the Arch- II ml II I Main Street Pharmacy 217 E. Main St.. Downtown Washington Phone: 254-5141 diocese of Chicago, the church in the United States and the Na- tional Conference of Catholic Bishops with dedication and dis- tinction." Cardinal Bernardin an- nounced his initiative, called the Catholic Common Ground Pro- ject, in Chicago Aug. 12. He said he hopes through a process of constructive dialogue to over- come the polarization that has debilitated the Catholic Church in the United States. Seven other bishops and 16 other Catholic leaders have formed an advisory committee to assist Cardinal Bernardin in the project. It is to be staffed by the National Pastoral Life Cen- Wade Funeral Home 119 S. Vine Street, Haubstadt, IN 768-5210 Call about pre-nced counseling, Robert J. Wade Alan J. Wade I I II ter in New York. One of its goals is to convene conferences on key issues facing the church in which Catholic representatives of different viewpoints come to- gether in dialogue. Funeral Homes , ,,,, Four Convenient Locations HIGHLAND CHAPEL 6300 FIRST AVENUE (812) 254-2641 0000.Kffm SAVINGS BANK, FSB 200 E. Van Trees St., Washington 500 Main St., Petersburg YOU SHOULD HEAR WHAT S00Na ABOUT US. "To haw someone you can depend an really means a lot. I don't know what we would have done without her." -- aUbf $dtt Oatt= ca),, IN "My whole life 15 felt that I have been drawn to do this type of wmk. And, |[you like somethin$ you will Jtcel at iL It's very rewarding to be a P"NP Ctfver. You mt have love in. your heart,, people matter ... I love wour for twe.. 1995 KREMPP LUMBER- CO, BUILDING MATERIAL SUPPLIES & GENERAL CONTRACTING HOMECENTER CONSTRUCTION -iUl 4a2 Stratman's Pharmacy City-Wide Delivery 413 Locust Street NU John and Judy Stratman V 425-5293 { Oak Hill Pharmacy l.p./d''" Prescription Specialists Hwy 62 and N. Welnbach Ave LARRY SCHULTHEIS Prol 425-4422 JASPER LUMBER CO. COMPLETE BUILDING SERVICE Ph: 482-1125 RT. 4, JASPER II II I III Christian Books & Gifts Bey & Charlie Mendel, owners (812)634-Tff 416 Jackson St. JaspeL IN 47546 i Please Support Message Advertisers PAUL'S PHABMACY Paul Mayer, Owner 2345 W. Franklin St. 425-4364 I I Plaza Pharmacy Newburgh Plaza Shopping Center Fast Proscription Service Ken and Rebecca Hacker 853-7141 question of "reception" -- how the faithful receive and incorpo- rate a decision or practice into their faith life -- as an element of discerning authentic faith or practice. "Surely this is an issue worthy of ongoing theological considers" tion," Cardinal Law said. But he warned that "reception by the faithful cannot be measured by polls." He cited the wide Catholic dis- agreement with the U.S. bishopS' pastoral letters on peace and on the economy and the unpopular" ity of the Massachusetts bishopS' stand on capital punishment as examples of the need for the church to teach "in season and out of season, when convenient and inconvenient." He acknowledged room for di- alogue on matters such as dis- agreements over prudential pas- toral judgments but said that when conflict involved "dissent from authoritative church teach" ing, that conflict cannot be dia- logued away. Dissent either yields to assent, or the conflict re- mains irresolvable." A good sign in truck equipment for Southwestern Indiana and Southeastern Illinois T.A. Brouillette & Son, Inc. features the complete line of Omaha Standard truck bodies and conversion hoists, scissor and "Olympic" telescopic. With Omaha Standard steel farm bodies you clet tough, .. '" - , 40" one-piece roll formed sides with built-in tarp rail, in 28, , and 52" heights, easy conversion stock racks, a full line ol rugged gates and the toughest platform in the businesS. "Clean Flow" Stakeless Steel Grain Bodies in 52 ", 60" and 72" heights. Ask about Omaha Standard's Service Bodies, Stake, Contractor, Dump Bodies and Liftgates. Stop by or call T.A. Brouillette & Son, Inc. for all your truck equipment needs. O Omaha Standard invites you to stop by or call T.A. Brouillette & Son, Inc. beScia C re Small Iajor , I"eritage, IIder, re